Business News

Maine's Push for Cross-Laminated Timber: An Opportunity for Local Industry and Sustainable Building

Table of Contents

  1. Key Highlights:
  2. Introduction
  3. The Quest for Local CLT Production
  4. Understanding Cross-Laminated Timber
  5. The Case for CLT in Maine
  6. Barriers to Industry Growth
  7. State Initiatives to Foster Local Production
  8. Regional Competition and Market Demand
  9. The Impact of Tariffs and Economic Dynamics
  10. Forward-Thinking Strategies for Sustainable Industry Growth
  11. Conclusion: The Future of CLT in Maine

Key Highlights:

  • Local Sourcing Challenge: Maine lacks cross-laminated timber (CLT) manufacturing facilities, necessitating transport of wood to distant states for processing, complicating local sourcing efforts.
  • Environmental Potential: CLT presents an environmentally friendly alternative to traditional materials like steel and concrete, offering significant sustainability benefits if local production can be established.
  • Market Barriers: Despite interest from companies and state incentives, a viable CLT industry in Maine faces financial and logistical challenges, raising questions about its future development.

Introduction

Maine, a state rich in natural resources and home to sprawling forests, has recently been in the spotlight regarding a promising yet underdeveloped building material—cross-laminated timber (CLT). While this innovative product presents a sustainable alternative to concrete and steel, it also exposes the logistical hurdles associated with establishing a local industry capable of producing it. The journey of Millard Dority, a former building manager at College of the Atlantic, embodies this struggle as he seeks to use local wood for a library expansion while confronting a broader issue: Maine's strategies for utilizing its timber resources and bolstering its forest economy.

The Quest for Local CLT Production

Millard Dority’s initiative at the Jesup Memorial Library in Bar Harbor highlights a critical void in Maine's manufacturing landscape. Drawing from his experience with College of the Atlantic, where two buildings utilized CLT sourced from Austria, he sought to engage local resources for the library project. His expectation was straightforward: with an abundance of forest land, Maine should easily produce the wood needed for CLT—if only there were a manufacturing facility nearby.

Currently, however, Maine does not host any CLT producers, forcing developers to transport timber to Illinois for processing before it can be sent back to Maine for use. This situation underscores a significant inefficiency in the supply chain and raises questions about the viability of growing a local CLT industry.

Understanding Cross-Laminated Timber

Cross-laminated timber is a cutting-edge building material made from gluing together multiple layers of solid wood boards with their grains oriented in perpendicular directions. This configuration provides superior strength and stability compared to traditional lumber while offering a lighter, more environmentally friendly alternative to heavier materials like steel and concrete. Initially popularized in Europe, CLT has seen limited adoption in the U.S. as builders look for reliable demonstrations of its capabilities.

Maine's adoption of CLT into its building code as of January 2021 marks a significant step toward recognizing its potential, yet the material's full integration into the construction market hinges on compelling examples of successful installations.

The Case for CLT in Maine

Ellen Belknap, principal at SMRT Architects & Engineers, encapsulates the need for success stories to inspire confidence among builders in the reliability of CLT. Projects like Dority’s library expansion aim to illustrate CLT's strength and versatility, particularly in commercial and institutional settings, where durability and sustainability are paramount.

Maine's growing CLT market can also lead to incorporating underutilized species, such as spruce-pine-fir and eastern hemlock, which are currently sourced for the library project from nearby states. Forestry expert Andy Fast highlights that these underused species present new opportunities for leveraging Maine's timber resources.

Barriers to Industry Growth

Attempts to establish CLT manufacturing facilities in Maine have not met with success. Two companies announced plans for factories in 2018, promising job creation and a boost to the local economy, but both projects failed to materialize. The state's economic development department, alongside private-sector partners, has been actively trying to recruit CLT manufacturers, yet outcomes have been hampered due to inadequate state incentives and a nascent market for CLT.

The complexity of Maine's timber supply chain—characterized by a large number of private woodlot owners—adds another layer of difficulty. Deeming the market sufficiently developed to support a manufacturing facility is critical, with estimates for start-up costs between $75 million to $150 million.

State Initiatives to Foster Local Production

Recognizing the opportunity CLT poses for economic development and environmental sustainability, state officials, including Charlotte Mace, the director of the Maine Office of Business Development, have begun wielding incentives to attract manufacturers. Programs such as Dirigo Business Incentives, which support workforce development and offer capital investment credits, aim to stimulate local industry growth.

Additionally, several high-profile projects, including the Jesup Library expansion and others like the Island Falls pedestrian bridge, are being funded to serve as case studies. As Mace notes, larger commercial or infrastructure projects frequently act as market drivers for new manufacturing facilities.

Regional Competition and Market Demand

Maine's competitive stance in attracting CLT producers is influenced by its East Coast neighbors, which have introduced various incentives to lure companies and develop the local market for mass timber. Massachusetts secured funding specifically for a CLT plant, and states like New York and Georgia are hosting programs designed to promote mass timber use in construction.

Despite these positive developments, Belknap emphasizes that until demand is sufficiently robust within Maine and the broader Northeast region, establishing a financially viable factory remains a challenge. High interest rates have concurrently slowed overall construction across the board, further complicating the landscape for CLT.

The Impact of Tariffs and Economic Dynamics

Economic considerations extend beyond local initiatives, as external factors like tariffs can significantly affect the viability of the CLT market. Uncertainty regarding potential tariffs on imported CLT from Canada or Europe can hinder market expansion. On the one hand, these tariffs might incentivize domestic production; on the other, they risk inflating costs related to construction materials, disrupting the balance of expenses associated with building projects.

Peter DelGreco, CEO of the economic development group Maine & Co., stresses the need for a regional approach to foster demand, emphasizing proximity to larger urban markets like Boston, New York, and Washington, D.C. Successful companies will likely require smart investments, favorable funding, and a keen eye on market conditions to thrive.

Forward-Thinking Strategies for Sustainable Industry Growth

Current discussions underscore the urgent need for a strategic vision to promote CLT in Maine. Shane O’Neill, the forest industry business development manager at the University of Maine, has outlined comprehensive recommendations advocating for incentives and collaborative efforts to nurture the industry. His research calls for the state to create more robust investment packages that can support innovative building projects and ultimately train the workforce involved in CLT production.

One significant move is Rep. Sam Zager's proposed $50 million bond bill aimed at financing CLT manufacturing facilities using Maine's sustainably harvested resources. With the support of the Maine Forest Products Council, this initiative could statistically bolster local employment while addressing the critical need for homegrown timber products.

Conclusion: The Future of CLT in Maine

As Maine endeavors to make strides in the CLT space, the collective interests of the government, private sector, and local communities must align to facilitate meaningful growth. The Jesup Memorial Library expansion is just one facet of a larger movement seeking to capitalize on Maine's lumber potential while advancing sustainable building practices.

Both local and regional strategies must be deployed to foster production, harness demand, and navigate the complexities of the timber supply chain. Only through concerted efforts can Maine hope to establish itself as a leader in the burgeoning CLT market, transforming its forests into vibrant, economic engines.

FAQ

What is cross-laminated timber (CLT)?
CLT is a wood building material created by gluing together layers of solid wood boards, oriented perpendicular to each other for added strength and stability. It serves as a sustainable alternative to concrete and steel.

Why does Maine not have local CLT manufacturing?
Despite significant interest and attempts to attract manufacturers, Maine currently lacks factories due to insufficient local market demand, complicated timber supply chains, and high start-up costs.

What are the benefits of using CLT in construction?
CLT offers environmental advantages over traditional materials, including reduced carbon emissions and lighter weight, while providing comparable or superior strength.

What initiatives are being taken to promote CLT in Maine?
State and local governments are working to attract manufacturers through incentives, funding for high-profile construction projects, and legislative support aimed at establishing CLT production facilities.

How does the supply chain impact the future of CLT in Maine?
The complexity of Maine’s timber supply chain, particularly the presence of numerous private woodlot owners, complicates efforts to create a robust local manufacturing environment for CLT products.

Are there any recent legislative efforts to support CLT in Maine?
Yes, a proposed $50 million bond bill aims to finance the establishment of a CLT manufacturing facility in Maine using sustainably harvested forest products, potentially transforming the state’s timber industry landscape.

About Growth Shuttle

The advisory practice of Mario Peshev

Mario Peshev is a value creation advisor to private equity firms and an active operator. He has founded six companies, exited two and advised over 500 since 2010, and he founded DevriX, a separate company that builds software.

Mario PeshevFounder, Growth Shuttle