Table of Contents
- Key Highlights:
- Introduction
- The Water Glass That Changed Everything
- The High Cost of the “Fail Fast” Mentality
- The Five Key Assessments to Foster Patient Innovation
- The Seventy Billion Dollar Proof
- Why This Really Matters
- Your Innovation Challenge
- The Questions That Change Everything
Key Highlights:
- The prevalent “fail fast” mantra in Silicon Valley may stifle potential breakthroughs by favoring immediacy over patient innovation.
- Former HP CTO Phil McKinney emphasizes five critical assessments for identifying ideas that merit patience, preventing premature project termination.
- The success of Bose's long-term research exemplifies the potential rewards of avoiding the “fail fast” approach, significantly enhancing the lives of truck drivers through innovative technology.
Introduction
In the fast-paced environment of technology and innovation, companies often face the daunting pressure to deliver results swiftly. The widely accepted aphorism "fail fast" has become a guiding principle in Silicon Valley, urging entrepreneurs to discard unsuccessful ideas quickly to stay ahead of the pack. However, this mindset may inadvertently quell transformative innovations before they reach fruition. Phil McKinney, a former CTO at HP, argues against this rushed approach, drawing attention to the profound costs associated with prematurely abandons promising ideas. Just as a still glass of water reveals the stability of Bose's revolutionary suspension system, the potential for breakthrough technologies can also exist hidden beneath turbulent pressures.
The Water Glass That Changed Everything
An illustrative story from McKinney's experience at Bose Corporation highlights the need for patience in innovation. During a visit to Dr. Bose's lab, McKinney witnessed a remarkable demonstration of a car seat that remained perfectly still on a chaotic car chassis. Initially unimpressed, his intrigue quickly grew when Dr. Bose placed a glass of water on the seat and drove over speed bumps at thirty miles per hour—none of the water spilled. This striking display represented half a century of research, demonstrating that such profound innovations require substantial time and persistence.
Dr. Bose's ability to allocate seven decades to the development of this technology stemmed from his company's private status, thereby freeing them from the quarterly pressures faced by public corporations. In contrast, HP's adherence to immediate results contributed to significant losses and missed opportunities, a fate McKinney would like to prevent others from experiencing.
The High Cost of the “Fail Fast” Mentality
The Mistakes of a Tech Giant
At HP, the relentless pursuit of quarterly earnings became a double-edged sword, systematically dismantling inventive ideas that did not yield quick results. McKinney recounts three pivotal examples that haunt him: WebOS, digital cameras, and the HP Halo telepresence project. Each of these innovations faced premature termination due to the unyielding demands placed on public companies for immediate performance.
WebOS is a prime case study. HP acquired Palm for $1.2 billion in 2010, captivated by its revolutionary interface. However, the project was abruptly abandoned when it failed to dominate the market swiftly. The user interface principles discarded during this decision would go on to inform modern app interactions we see today—a costly oversight.
In another instance, HP invented digital cameras, yet abandoned the initiative as smartphones began integrating this aspect into their functionality. The regret is palpable; HP's lost opportunity to lead in the camera revolution was a result of its failure to recognize the long-term potential of such technology.
The HP Halo project, a state-of-the-art telepresence solution, was also sacrificed at the altar of quarterly demand. A sale to Polycom at $89 million was a fraction of its worth, which eventually led HP to invest substantially more to reacquire similar capabilities years later. The cycle of immense attrition imposed by a focus on short-term outcomes fundamentally undermined HP's competitive edge during this period.
Assessing Innovations with a New Lens
In the wake of these setbacks, McKinney has since adopted a new framework for evaluating the potential of innovative ideas. He advises a careful analysis of five essential criteria before deciding whether to proceed or abandon a project.
The Five Key Assessments to Foster Patient Innovation
1. Does the Math Actually Work?
The first criterion hinges upon scientific validation. Leaders should turn to peer-reviewed journals and rely on assessments from independent experts to validate the math behind an innovation. Overly complex models may hide fundamental flaws; a focus on mathematical elegance is crucial. For McKinney, the imperative is clear: conduct comprehensive evaluations and cease investment should experts express concerns over the foundational science.
2. Can You Actually Build the Pieces?
Successful innovations require the effective orchestration of various technologies. A dependency map helps track the necessary components for realization, assessing their development statuses. When a project relies on "magic"—unproven and uncertain breakthroughs—the risk amplifies. Identifying realistic timelines for every critical piece is paramount to safeguarding against overambition.
3. Will Anyone Actually Want This?
A deep understanding of the market landscape is vital in assessing innovation viability. McKinney underscores the need to conduct thorough pain-point analysis to determine whether the solution offers genuine value. Recognizing regulatory shifts can also create large opportunities for adopted technologies, particularly in industries influenced by evolving standards. Identifying early adopters who are willing to invest in an imperfect solution establishes a foundation for validation and market entry.
4. Will You Have Time to Enjoy It?
Developing innovations must be about creating defensible market advantages. It's essential to differentiate between component improvements and system-level innovations, which require a broader expertise to develop. The longevity associated with accumulated knowledge defines competitive barriers to entry; thus, innovators should contemplate how long it would take for competitors to catch up, even with significant financial backing.
5. Can You Actually Survive the Wait?
The most critical assessment revolves around the organization's endurance to sustain investment in the innovation. A brutal, honest evaluation of funding horizons, key decision-makers’ patience, and precautionary measures against potential setbacks is imperative. Organizations must develop mechanisms to protect project funding from being undermined by short-term pressures.
The Seventy Billion Dollar Proof
The intricacies of effective innovation management can be illustrated through Dell's successful 2013 privatization. Michael Dell pursued this strategy primarily to escape the suffocating quarterly earnings scrutiny. By doing so, Dell increased R&D expenditure drastically, transitioning from a struggling PC company to a leader in enterprise solutions with an estimated $70 billion return by 2023. This example stands as a testament to the value of patient capital, emphasizing that long-term vision and flexibility foster innovative success.
Why This Really Matters
Bose's innovation, encompassing the Ride system, materialized in 2010 and markedly improved quality of life for truck drivers facing significant health issues due to whole-body vibrations without prior technological solutions. Testimonials from those impacted reinforce the significance of long-term innovation development. By clinging to a myopic “fail fast” philosophy, many innovations that could drastically improve lives would never see the light of day.
Your Innovation Challenge
Businesses must examine their existing portfolios for projects that require time to blossom and possess foundational validity but have not yet achieved commercial traction. Instead of yielding to short-term pressures, organizations should be prepared to protect and nurture their most promising innovations.
Opting for the seventy-twenty-ten model of investment can allow businesses to allocate resources strategically: dedicating a majority of efforts toward core improvements, with a fraction channeled into adjacent and transformational innovations. Embracing patient innovation cultivates technological barriers that cannot be quickly replicated, leading to sustainable long-term success.
The Questions That Change Everything
Finally, organizations should reevaluate their approach by shifting inquiries away from immediate market entry and costs. Instead, focus on understanding the fundamental challenges impeding breakthroughs, the long-term potential of projects, and the boundaries to overcoming obstacles. Building resilience within innovation ecosystems ultimately delineates which companies will thrive and which will falter.
What innovation in your own organization could benefit from patience rather than rapid termination? This pivotal question could determine whether you are at the forefront of the next significant breakthrough or stifling it before it has the opportunity to prosper.
FAQ
What is the “fail fast” mentality?
It is a prevalent approach in technology and startups that emphasizes quickly identifying and eliminating unsuccessful ideas to focus resources on more promising projects.
How can organizations assess whether an idea is worth pursuing?
Key assessments include validating scientific principles, ensuring technical feasibility, identifying target markets, understanding competitive advantages, and evaluating organizational endurance.
What’s an example of successful patient innovation?
Dell's privatization in 2013 exemplifies patient innovation, yielding a remarkable transformation and substantial returns by prioritizing long-term R&D investment over quarterly pressures.
Why is patient innovation crucial?
It allows businesses to cultivate breakthrough technologies, significantly impacting quality of life and market landscapes while ensuring competitive advantage in the long run.
How can businesses defend against short-term pressures?
Implementing structural protections, such as dedicated funding for innovative projects and insulated project teams, can safeguard long-term investments from immediate financial pressures.


