Business News

Thematic Funds: A Double-Edged Sword in Investment Strategies

Table of Contents

  1. Key Highlights:
  2. Introduction
  3. The Surge of Thematic Funds
  4. Promises and Performance: A Discrepancy
  5. The Risks of Thematic Investing
  6. The Role of Timing in Thematic Investments
  7. Assessing Long-Term Viability
  8. The Future of Thematic Funds
  9. Conclusion: Navigating the Thematic Terrain

Key Highlights:

  • Thematic and sectoral funds have surged in popularity, raising over Rs. 88,000 crore in 2024, significantly outpacing traditional equity funds.
  • Despite substantial inflows, many thematic funds have underperformed, with nearly 48% failing to exceed the Nifty 500 Index's returns within a year of inception.
  • Investors are advised to exercise caution and consider portfolio diversification, with thematic funds ideally constituting no more than 25% of equity investments.

Introduction

The investment landscape in India has witnessed a dramatic shift with the advent of thematic and sectoral funds. These funds, often positioned as the knights in shining armor, promise to deliver returns aligned with specific macroeconomic trends or sectoral narratives. Their rise to fame can be likened to ancient gladiators entering the Colosseum, attracting a throng of eager investors ready to place their bets on the next big winner. However, the reality has proven to be less than spectacular, with many of these funds failing to deliver on their lofty promises. This article delves into the performance of thematic funds, examining the narratives that drive them, the risks they entail, and the strategic considerations investors must keep in mind.

The Surge of Thematic Funds

In the wake of market optimism in 2024, a record number of new fund offerings (NFOs) emerged, with a striking 73 of the 180 NFOs falling within the thematic category. The allure of these funds lies in their ability to capitalize on trending sectors such as electric vehicles, defense, and public sector undertakings. Rajani Tandale, Senior Vice President at 1 Finance, notes that fund houses have aggressively marketed these thematic opportunities, enticing investors with tales of exponential growth.

Investors responded enthusiastically, contributing a staggering Rs. 88,000 crore to thematic funds, a meteoric rise from the mere eight thematic launches in 2022. Data from the Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI) reveals a remarkable tripling of assets under management (AUM) in thematic funds, soaring from Rs. 1.7 trillion in March 2023 to Rs. 5.1 trillion by June 2025. In comparison, the AUM in flexi-cap funds, which generally offer a more diversified investment approach, only doubled during the same period.

Promises and Performance: A Discrepancy

Despite the robust inflows, the performance of many thematic funds has been lackluster. Investors who anticipated windfall returns have encountered a sobering reality. The average return across new thematic offerings has languished at a mere 5% since their inception, with only a handful of funds, such as the WhiteOak Capital Special Opportunities and Motilal Oswal Business Cycle, achieving returns exceeding 25%.

The largest fund, the HDFC Manufacturing Fund, raised Rs. 9,563 crore but has only yielded a 9.57% return since its inception. The ICICI Prudential Energy Opportunities Fund, which attracted Rs. 8,531 crore in July 2024, has performed even worse, returning only 5.4%. Alarmingly, 19 thematic funds are currently operating at a loss, highlighting the risks associated with chasing trendy investment narratives.

The Risks of Thematic Investing

While the concept of thematic investing is appealing, it also carries inherent risks. Thematic funds often rely on macroeconomic narratives that can be fleeting. Over-reliance on compelling stories without solid underlying fundamentals can lead to disappointing performance. As Tandale points out, many thematic funds launched recently lack the necessary earnings growth from their underlying companies to support their valuations, making them susceptible to underperformance.

Time is another critical factor in the success of thematic funds. Investors must navigate the cyclical nature of these investments, entering and exiting at the right moments. Unfortunately, many investors tend to hold onto these funds long after the initial enthusiasm has waned, often leading to losses. The responsibility of managing entry and exit decisions ultimately falls on the investor, a task that can be daunting in a volatile market.

The Role of Timing in Thematic Investments

Timing is essential when considering thematic funds. Investors need to be acutely aware of market cycles and the prevailing economic environment. According to Tandale, thematic and sectoral funds can fall out of favor and underperform for extended periods. The key challenge lies in the fact that many of these funds are launched when there is already a significant tailwind supporting them, often leading to inflated valuations.

To mitigate risk, investors should approach thematic funds with caution. Banka, a seasoned investment advisor, suggests that thematic funds should constitute no more than 25% of an individual’s equity fund portfolio, with any single theme limited to 10%. This diversification strategy can help safeguard against potential downturns in specific sectors or themes.

Assessing Long-Term Viability

While thematic funds can offer investors exposure to emerging sectors and trends, their long-term viability remains uncertain. The recent performance of many funds serves as a stark reminder that narratives alone do not guarantee success. Investors must seek out funds backed by strong fundamentals and earnings growth to enhance their chances of success.

The lack of immediate returns from thematic funds has prompted many investors to reassess their strategies. Those who have recently allocated significant amounts to these funds are encouraged to recalibrate their investments. For individuals with a time horizon extending beyond three years, maintaining investment in thematic funds may be appropriate, provided their exposure remains within recommended limits. Conversely, investors needing liquidity or those uncomfortable with the inherent risks should consider reallocating to diversified funds like flexi-cap or multi-cap options.

The Future of Thematic Funds

Looking ahead, the future of thematic funds will depend on several factors, including macroeconomic conditions, sectoral performance, and investor sentiment. The current environment indicates that investors may be more cautious when considering new thematic offerings, especially as the market matures and more data becomes available on performance metrics.

Fund managers will also need to adapt their strategies to align with investor expectations. This may involve providing clearer guidance on the underlying fundamentals of their funds and focusing on themes with robust growth potential. As investor awareness grows, the demand for transparency and accountability in thematic funds is likely to increase.

Conclusion: Navigating the Thematic Terrain

Thematic funds can undoubtedly add value to an investment portfolio, offering targeted exposure to specific sectors or trends. However, the recent performance of many of these funds underscores the importance of due diligence and careful selection. Investors should remain vigilant, ensuring their investments are grounded in strong fundamentals rather than mere narratives.

As the investment landscape continues to evolve, a balanced approach that incorporates thematic funds within a diversified portfolio may yield the best results. By adhering to sound investment principles and maintaining a long-term perspective, investors can navigate the complexities of thematic investing while mitigating potential risks.

FAQ

What are thematic funds?
Thematic funds are mutual funds that invest in specific sectors or themes based on macroeconomic trends or narratives, such as technology, healthcare, or renewable energy.

Why have thematic funds gained popularity?
Thematic funds have gained traction due to their potential for high returns, as they focus on sectors expected to outperform the broader market based on current trends and macroeconomic factors.

What are the risks associated with investing in thematic funds?
The primary risks include poor performance due to reliance on narratives without solid fundamentals, market volatility, and the challenge of timing market entry and exit.

How can investors mitigate risks when investing in thematic funds?
Investors can mitigate risks by limiting their exposure to thematic funds within their portfolios, diversifying their investments, and conducting thorough research on the underlying fundamentals of the funds they choose.

Are thematic funds suitable for all investors?
Not necessarily. While thematic funds can offer significant returns, they also come with higher risks. They may be more suitable for investors with a higher risk tolerance and a longer investment horizon.

About Growth Shuttle

The advisory practice of Mario Peshev

Mario Peshev is a value creation advisor to private equity firms and an active operator. He has founded six companies, exited two and advised over 500 since 2010, and he founded DevriX, a separate company that builds software.

Mario PeshevFounder, Growth Shuttle